Ending Racism at Toyota Park
Posted by: Tom Dunmore in Section 8 on Aug 07, 2008
What is it like to be part of one of the Fire's most dedicated, positive and vibrant supporters' groups and yet to face continual, racially motivated abuse from security at Toyota Park? Ask Sector Latino, who have been targeted since their emergence in 2005 by Monterrey Security, and who received disgraceful racist abuse from guards at the last home game against Chivas USA.
Following this, Section 8 Chicago called a series of meeting to explore the details of the situation and put together a course of action to resolve the problem. In sum, it was determined that Section 8 must stand in solidarity with SL and that Monterrey's racist guards can no longer be present in the section.
Backdraft was present and offers a full report on proceedings below.
Explaining Sector Latino's Situation
Last night, around 25 people met on short notice to determine a course of action. Present were several members of Sector Latino, the Section 8 Chicago board, representatives of various supporters groups, independent Fire fans, and club seat holders.
The meeting documented the history of Sector Latino's dealings with security, the specific incidents that took place at the Chivas game last Saturday, and featured discussion on what action Section 8 should take as a consequence.
The meeting began with Walter Arredondo, leader of Sector Latino, outlining the history of Sector Latino and the problems they have had since they first started coming to games at Soldier Field in 2005. Walter explained that they had been kicked out in the past for "making noise" (as they were told by security), and feels that the Fire do not understand their style of support. SL members said they feel they are singled out and harassed at every single game.
Sector Latino pointed out they have tried to reason and open dialog with Monterrey Security officials on numerous occasions. Walter said he has identified himself as a leader to discuss matters, but has received no reciprocation from Monterrey.
Walter explained that security has, for some time, waited for and tailed Sector Latino around both inside and outside the stadium -- before, during, and after games. All at the meeting agreed that no other supporters group faces this treatment, and that SL is being singled out for harassment within Section 8.
The S8C board pointed out that the club does not treat Sector Latino as a group under the Section 8 Chicago umbrella like all other affiliated groups, noting that problems are not addressed via the S8C Chair as is common practice otherwise. Chairman Ben Burton stated that this must stop, as SL is as valued and legitimate as any other group. Despite SL's known anti-gang stance, it was pointed out that numerous regulars are often asked if SL are "gangbangers" by Monterrey guards, who refer to the group in derogatory terms.
The Chivas Game
The discussion then turned to the details of the previous game, which brought a new low in SL-Monterrey relations. Sector Latino were standing in their regular spot in section 117 with tickets for that section. It has been agreed by the club with S8C that 117 is a general admission section, like 118. Despite this, the club sold numbered tickets to the section, including to Chivas fans.
When other fans showed up with these numbered tickets, SL stated they were not politely asked to move elsewhere, but herded aggressively out of the entire section. They felt this was an unnecessary escalation of the situation. Walter attempted to talk to a Monterrey guard about this, but he refused to discuss the matter.
Sector Latino then explained that they received racial abuse from Monterrey guards, being called "spics" and "wetbacks". Other SL members noted that in general, Monterrey's first response is always to charge in and provoke confrontation, rather than to engage in discussion. It was added that they also made abusive gestures to SL members.
Once outside in the lot, one SL member had his thumb broken when violently thrown down. Another SL member believes security stole his personal property, including a camera that had filmed some of Monterrey's abusive gestures. Another member had his glasses broken.
Taking Action
The meeting then turned to decide on what action to take. The Section 8 Chicago board proposed a series of actions, and some non-negotiable points, as follows:
- It has been concluded that Monterrey are dealing with SL in a racist manner, and have been doing so for some time; the latest incident with direct verbal racist abuse provides final proof of this and renders Monterrey's presence at the stadium intolerable. The S8C board has warned the Fire of the problem on numerous occasions previously, and no positive action has been taken by the club. The board feel that the Fire have failed to take sufficient charge of the situation.
- It was emphasised that Sector Latino is just as much a part of Section 8 as any other group. It cannot be permitted that they are singled out and followed around or treated differently than any other group due to racial profiling.
- Therefore, the onus is on the Fire -- who can and should control the situation -- to provide a resolution. The buck can no longer be passed around between the Fire (who no longer have a security liaison), Toyota Park, and Monterrey. These incidents are taking place at Chicago Fire games and it is their responsibility to ensure racism and mistreatment of fans by security never occurs again.
- The board expressed that Monterrey must be removed from the stadium, or at the very least, from sections 117 and 118 and security cannot be allowed to tail and harass Sector Latino anywhere in the stadium.
- The board explained that this is non-negotiable, as Monterrey have on numerous occasions promised to stamp out the unprofessional behavior of their staff, yet the situation has only regressed. It can no longer be accepted on faith that things will improve.
- The board mentioned that both NY and DC have dealt with security targeting supporters' groups by removing the companies responsible from the supporters' sections, and replacing them with police officers or a self-policing stewarding system.
- Finally, a consensus was reached amongst those present in support of S8C's general stance that Monterrey can no longer be tolerated in Section 8. Club seat holders present pointed out they have different but also serious problems with Monterrey, and it was felt their removal from the entire stadium would be the best course of action by the club.
If Monterrey is not removed, an escalating course of action was discussed. To begin with, a specific protest action at the upcoming DC home game was outlined:
- A sit-in will be held in the first half after a joint walk-in together with Sector Latino, with no songs, drums or regular banners from Section 8. At some point in the first half, Sector Latino will begin their singing, and should be the only group making noise until half-time. In the second half, regular section support will resume full power.
- Sector Latino will sit in the middle of the section in the first half, surrounded by other regulars. They will hold up two banners, one in English and one in Spanish, appealing to the Fire's owner and Blanco to help the situation. It was generally thought that if these two influential figures were aware of the details of Monterrey's racism and aggressive "security", the situation would be resolved.
- S8C will broadcast news of the protest ahead of the game, and organize the action within the stadium, with the help of supporters' groups. It was felt important to inform fans in other areas of the stadium of the situation as much as possible.
- S8C have contacted DC's travelling fans about the planned action, who are sympathetic to the situation.
- It was repeatedly emphasized that those in the section should remain calm during the protest, and do nothing to provoke Monterrey. It will be a peaceful protest.
As the meeting wound down, tentative proposals for further serious action should Monterrey remain after the DC game were outlined. These will be revisited at a later date, but an escalating series of protests was determined to be the best course of action.
The meeting concluded with a general consensus in support of this action and expressions of solidarity with SL.
|
El Guapo
August 07, 2008 |
I really hope the Fire Organization gets on top of this. I would hate to have the club that I love being associated as a racist. The FO knows about the situation and if nothing is done on their part to end racism towards their customers then we have no choice then to hit them where it hurts....... |
|
giaco
August 07, 2008 |
How it's gone on this far with everyone in the organisation passing the buck is very dissappointing and saddening. |
|
El Guapo
August 07, 2008 |
Racism is ignorance. |
|
Ben
August 07, 2008 |
Zero tolerance means we can't turn a blind eye. Racism has no equal, and deserves no negotiations. |
|
EL Tiger
August 08, 2008 |
I think they have to act, I think all I have heard from the TP so far sounds a tad bit like blame the victim. Whatever happened after the game does not equal the treatment SL has recieved since 05'. The Fire has to act against the racist security agency. The complaints they will recieve for supporting racists will be devastating to the future growth of the active fan base. There has been a significant increase in season ticket holders from this year compared to last, and if they expect it to continue they have stomp out this plague... |
|
Jesse(S*L)
August 09, 2008 |
Racism should not be tolerated in any way, shape, or form... Isn't it ironic how the owner of MS is in fact mexican himself and allows his staff and company be little and racially harass his own people?? This company in its entirety has been demeaned as being low class and unprofessional... I hope with all of my might that situation is defused and resolved properly and accordingly... Awante Mi Banda!!! |
|
benjamin meza
August 10, 2008 |
This cant go on and i applaud S8 on their actions. I am behind them 100% |
|
Dave
August 12, 2008 |
What can I, as a season ticket-holder who does not sit in 117 or 118, do to help support all of the supporter's groups on the day of the protest? |
|
Ben
August 12, 2008 |
Dave, join our email list (Join US at the top of the page) as we'll be putting out details as soon as we can. The ISA had a meeting with the team yesterday and another tomorrow. |
|
rathcelt
August 14, 2008 |
The Fire couldn't buy what section 8 brings to the games. Ultimately, S8 may have to remove themselves for a game and watch the atmosphere and attendance drop. Racism is antisoccer, anti-everything worthwhile, and just plain stupid. Perhaps a more direct contact with Haupman is in order. |
|
Pestilence
August 14, 2008 |
I watched a SL member throw a plastic soda bottle at a Monterrey guard during the Chivas game. It should be noted that respect needs to flow both ways. |
|
Grant
August 15, 2008 |
There's no place for racism in football, here in the UK we've battled it for years. |
|
Colin
August 15, 2008 |
Sad day for sure.... |
|
Yikes
August 15, 2008 |
You are making a HUGE mistake by trying to portray this as a racism. It isn't, and the Fire only need to point out the large numbers of Hispanic FAMILIES that attend their games as proof. |
|
Che!SL!51!
August 15, 2008 |
Shut Up YIKES!!!!! I think we know they're based in Pilsen u idiot.... And what monterey means...Maybe you should do your research before You say something on here... read up on Juan Gaytan and da company's relationship with the Hispanic Democratic Organization... HDO!!!!! If You don't know anything about the HDO, It was started by AL Sanchez.... AL Sanchez!!!!!!! Now if you know nothing about AL Sanchez and his political ties and crookedness, you can call yourslef ignorant... So once again YIKES, do your research before you say anything.... |
|
Fire fan
August 15, 2008 |
Hummm, Yikes speaks common sense and gets attacked for it? Get real, the racism claim here is ridiculous and SL is not innocent in this matter. I have seen the conduct in their section and they have some cleaning up to do. I cannot believe the charge managed to get press in the Tribune. |
|
Hendo
August 15, 2008 |
"Your conduct is getting more and more out of hand as the season and the Fire go on" |
|
Tom Dunmore
August 15, 2008 |
Yikes: SL have reported they received racist abuse and have multiple witnesses. They have reported the guard's number to the Fire. Nothing has been done. In general, Monterrey are targeting SL differently from other group in Section 8, from regular searches when they go in that other fans at the gates do not receive, tailing them around and calling them 'spics' and 'wetbacks'. The fact Monterrey operate out of Pilsen and are owned by Juan Gayton is neither here nor there. |
|
irishoutsider
August 15, 2008 |
@fire fan season ticket holder |
|
El Guapo
August 15, 2008 |
I wonder if those who are saying that we are blowing this out of porportion would say the same thing if this had happened to a supporter group made up of Mid-West All-Amercan Anglo supporters. |
|
giaco
August 15, 2008 |
Get real, the racism claim here is ridiculous (were you standing there when security called SL what they did? that IS NOT ridiculous, that is real) and SL is not innocent in this matter(no one said that anyone was any kind of little lamb--but when are racial slurs appropriate methods of crowd control?). I have seen the conduct in their section (our section? Right....so stay in your own and there's no prob) and they have some cleaning up to do (celaning up of what, and why? Without citing something, you have nothing). I cannot believe the charge managed to get press in the Tribune (you're right, no one takes interest in racism in a town with such a large minority population....wake up, this ain't Iowa). |
|
Mike E
August 15, 2008 |
"I watched a SL member throw a plastic soda bottle at a Monterrey guard during the Chivas game. It should be noted that respect needs to flow both ways." |
|
OutsidePerspective
August 15, 2008 |
I read the S8 boards from time to time, but don't post so I thought I'd post it here in the hopes that S8 members will read it (or better yet, copy it over there). I'm a season ticket holder that never misses a game. I don't sit in Section 8 (nor do I want to), but I love the atmosphere that all of you bring to the stadium. Looking at the drama that's arisen, I thought you might like an outsider's opinion. |
|
El Guapo
August 15, 2008 |
OutsidePerpective, |
|
Folsom
August 15, 2008 |
I will offer up a little unsolicited advice on this matter and you can take it for what you want. |
|
John Bosch
August 15, 2008 |
I don't condone what security did at the last Fire home game, but I think it should be handled differently than with your specific protests. First of all, if this was going on since 2005 then why wasn't it handled then. I think a better protest, other than remaining silent and walking in together, would be to not show up at all. Since you are going to the game, you are technically still supporting the Fire organization even if you don't cheer. Also, you are drawing more attention to yourselves and showing up the players on the field(who have nothing to do with this) by remaining silent during the first half. Lastly, if the Fire organization, Monterrey or Village of Bridgeview don't want to do anything about this then Section 8 needs to take this case to a higher authority. I will be cheering as loud as I can for a Fire win tomorrow. Go Fire! |
|
Flanagan
August 16, 2008 |
John Bosch: rule one in organizing, leave yourself the room and ability to escalate. No need to throw the baby out with the bathwater. Besides, that would be unreasonable. You say our demands are unreasonable. We don't agree. Yet, you recommend we not even come to the game. We don't agree. Why instead of othering us, not come and talk to us tomorrow before the match about what has happened? Give us and yourself a chance to meet us and see all of this for it is, in a more balanced light. |
|
Flanagan
August 16, 2008 |
(continued from above) |
|
Flanagan
August 16, 2008 |
Sorry. It's erroneously, not "erroniously." Guess I really am a stickler for the details. My apologies. |
|
Monterrey Employee
August 16, 2008 |
Up until last evening, when browsing through the Chicago Tribue, I had been unaware of the racist allegations put forth by the supporters of Section 9. However, it certainly comes as no surprise. I should mention now I'm currently employed by Monterrey Security, and -- in addition to several other venues -- occassionally attend events at Toyota Park. I'll give you my account of what has transpired recently (as I don't know the entire history) and why your attempts to resolve this situation will ultimately go unheeded. |
|
Monterrey Employee
August 16, 2008 |
My advice is not to act like you're a legitimate organization by attempting to impose "non negotiable" terms. Everyone at Monterrey is probably laughing at this. Oh, and in case any of you are curious --The Fire, Guest Services, Toyota Park personnel; they're all friendly with Monterrey's upper tier personnel. Ive seen them interact. Why else would complaints go unanswered? It's a non issue to them. |
|
Zapata
August 16, 2008 |
"Or, just several weeks ago, two fans scaled the barrier and ran onto the field? For such a small percentage of the total stadium area your section has disproportionately the highest amount of trouble. Thus, more security guards." |
|
Ben
August 16, 2008 |
We've put together an F.A.Q. to try and help keep the information clear and accurate. If we continue to get a lot of repeat questions we'll update the F.A.Q. with the questions and answers. |
|
Darryl
August 16, 2008 |
Thanks S8 for your leadership on this issue. While I and my family do not sit in Section 8 please know that you will have our active support. |
|
Cristiano
August 16, 2008 |
i must say, as a strong Fire supporter, this "demonstration" tonight was merely a staged performances by headless baffoons! i was emberrassed to see you SL-demonstrators acting that way. whichever genius came up with this "silent protest" idea might as well have been sitting on the DC corner. For gosh sakes,...DC sounded more united than we did! we all saw how much your silence helped our team tonight (but i guess thats not what Section 8 are for anymore). if you werent outraged by this pitiful "performance" then i would definitely question your loyalty to the club and your intelligence. SL have CLEARLY forgotten the purpose of a team supporters club. handle this directly with Toyota Park Mgmnt & their pockets. what message are you sending to anyone by sitting DUMB and unsupportive of your supposed team during the first half,...yet continue to buy their beverages and eat their food. Here in America, when you're affecting someone's pocketbooks, then and ONLY then, will you have volume in your case. This isnt meant to be racist in anyway, but rather to cause you to think before being another puppet in the crowd. just something to think about...how many of you took those Section Latino shirts not knowing the situation on hand this evening? |
|
Darren
August 17, 2008 |
I was at this game and they broke the back rest on the bench we were sitting on. It was awesome! |
|
Zapata
August 17, 2008 |
Cristiano, |
|
Chicago Fire Employee
August 17, 2008 |
I suppose I'll join the anonymous employees commenting here. |
|
Charles
August 17, 2008 |
Follow Up: Last night I came with my family made up of my wife and two daughters. While we don't sit in Section 8 we did stroll the parking lot before hand and purchsed shirts for the whole family. One nice young man handed us small fliers explaining what would be happening in Section 8. |
|
El Guapo
August 17, 2008 |
Charles, |
|
Holly Fire
August 17, 2008 |
I was at the game last night. I couldn't tell any difference in the "atmosphere of the stadium" with your protest though I thought the DC fans were great, loud, organized, spirited, polite and good fun. |
|
Holly Fire
August 17, 2008 |
By the way, your silly little "sit-in" didn't even make the news. |
|
RomaDame
August 17, 2008 |
Hey, |
|
El Guapo
August 17, 2008 |
Thanks Holly for pointing that out. |
|
Steph
August 18, 2008 |
I just wanted to say that even though it was hard to stay quiet that I feel that it was important to show support for those who have shown support for the team that I love more than anything in the world. I hope that management wakes up so that we can get back to what we do best, supporting the greatest team on earth! |
|
Krasny
August 18, 2008 |
"Your claims are racism are an easy excuse for you and your "leaders" to climb up on a soap box. Go find another cause, please, you are just embarrasing yourself and I hope Sector Latino realize they are just pawns in Liam's current drama." |
|
dank
August 18, 2008 |
Sorry for what will be a long post...You know, I watch all the games on my50 and make it out to the few I can afford (times are rough these days). There was NO mention of the protest nor any crowd shots of Section 8 during the entire DC United game. That's very odd and disrespectful of the situation. Whether it's bad for business or not, everyone needs to recognize the reality of what's going on. |
|
EL Tiger
August 20, 2008 |
Holly you are just silly, it made the cover of Hoy, which because you know so little, is more impact ful than the other media.... |
|
Holly Fire
August 20, 2008 |
El Tiger, |
|
Jimmy
August 20, 2008 |
Preaching to the choir!?! I'm not even sure where to start on that comment. Wow. Yeah, you're right- ....... actually, I can't even think of a sarcastic remark. That was ignorant and uncalled for. |
|
EL Tiger
August 22, 2008 |
Holly preaching to the choir? What, I guess if all the Latinos who read Hoy get upset I guess that doesn't matter does it? |
|
Season ticket holder
September 03, 2008 |
Let's not confuse the SL complaints with the views of the Latino fan community as a whole. There are a LOT of Latino fans sitting in assigned seating who do not appreciate some of the antics from S8. Contrary to belief of some on this board, Latinos are not monolithic in their views on this issue and to say so is, quite frankly, racist. Too many people are trying to make this a general race issue when in reality it is more a section 8 and SL issue. To generalize is oft the refuge of the rascal. |
|
Footballer
September 24, 2008 |
Why does that guy play the Tetris song on his horn? What does Tetris have to do with the Fire or with football? I would understand if the Russian community was bigger here in Chicago, but it isn't. I say stick with these chants: |








